Covid-19 Announcements

Temporary Store Hours

Tuesday - Saturday 7am - 4pm
Sunday 7am - 1pm
Now Until Further Notice

Drive up pick up lane

We will have a drive up, pick up lane on Brady Street, for pick up orders. This allows for safe social distancing and minimizes the amount of customers in our store at one time.


5 cookies of your choice or 1/4lb inside a clear 4x4x2 food safe plastic box with crinkle paper, topped with a thank you sticker.  A perfect way to keep your guests safe and prevent them from grabbing off of a shared dessert table.


Fresh From the Oven Daily
At Peter Sciortino Bakery, we make all of our products from scratch daily, using only the highest quality ingredients, to ensure that our customers receive the freshest baked goods in Milwaukee. From our amazingly fresh Italian breads, & rolls to our delicious Italian cookies & pastries, we assure you that you will not find a fresher or better tasting bakery in the Greater Milwaukee area!

The Best in Milwaukee
Named Milwaukee's best bakery by the Shepherd Express and, Peter Sciortino Bakery takes enormous pride in the quality, service and of course, taste of our products. Stop by, and see and taste for yourself why we have been voted Milwaukee's Best! We ship anywhere in the United States.