We take pride in the quality and freshness of our products. At Peter Sciortino's Bakery, we make all of our products from scratch on a daily basis to ensure that our customers receive the freshest baked goods in Milwaukee. From our amazingly fresh breads to our delicious Italian pastries, we assure you that you will not find a fresher or better tasting bakery in the Greater Milwaukee area!


"The Best Little Bakeshop in America Is Right Here in Milwaukee." 
Click here to read the full article!

The Beginning

1947 - 1996

In 1947 Peter C. Sciortino and his wife Grace established PETER SCIORTINO BAKERY. The aroma of fresh baked breads, rolls and cookies has since filled the Brady Street neighborhood.  

The Vella's

1997 - TODAY

In 1997 Peter and Grace sold their bakery to three young, ambitious, and energetic employees. You all know them as Maria, Joe and Luigi Vella. Working first for the Sciortino's as young teenagers, the Vella’s grew up learning the business from the bottom up.  

Much of the traditional breads, rolls, cookies and pastries can still be found all over the city, whether it’s at your local Sendiks, Piggly Wiggly, or Sentry or perhaps at your favorite restaurant The Vella’s have introduced many new types of cookies and expanded the bread and roll line to accommodate the current times and demand. 

Did You Know?


We have expanded our business so we can now can ship our cookies and breads to you anywhere in the United States and sometimes even overseas.  Click here to shop online.


No order is too small or too large. We welcome both retail and wholesale customers.

We do special orders for any occasion like weddings, showers and meetings. We can also do special orders for those with an allergy or a specific dietary needs.


Just recently we remodeled our store, when was the last time you stopped in? Come check us out, you won’t be disappointed.

The freshest baked goods in Milwaukee!- Order Online Today!